Tom David
Ansys Employee

Hello Albin,

The two scale factor both using 1.95 should be the same. this wasn`t the case with earlier versions, so make sure you are using an updated version 
The FEA results you get in both cases should be the same, but, in order to compare apples to apples, follow the exact way Sherlock uses the strain results taking into account nodal vs elemental results and type of strain. 

Thank you,