Guilin Sun
Ansys Employee

Sorry to reply you late due to ceratin circumstances.

From your results, it seems the S parameter has some issues, at it changes violently. It might have higher differaction orders. Please use farfield option to pick up only yhr zero-th order.

In addition, dupicating other's result can be very challenge, as the original authors may not give clear details. Sometimes people use the same concept but different math definitions. For example, left-and right- circular polarization can be opposite. TE and TM modes have the same issues.

Please refer this post to check if everything is the same as the paper:

Ansys Insight: Why my simulation result is different from published paper or experiment?