July 11, 2023 at 8:41 amRuzanSubscriber
We are interested in simulating high quality factor metasurface structures with quality factors of 50,000. When using conventional Lumerical engine licenses, the simulation lasts ~12 hours even if I use 120 cores. I am wondering if someone has benchmarked Lumerical FDTD vs. Comsol. Does anyone know if it is more optimal to use Lumerical or Comsol when considering high quality factor structures?
Also, has anyone studied which software (Lumerical or Comsol) provides more accurate result within a reasonable time frame?
July 11, 2023 at 9:53 pmGuilin SunAnsys Employee
Comparing performance is very challenge and depends several factors. Lumerical's FDTD is the benchmark in the maret for a long time and with proper settings it is the fastest of its kind, in particular in 3D simulations.
Are you only interested in the quality factor and resonance frequency, or total transmission? if it is only qualifactor and resonance, it should be much faster as it does not need to simulate to fulfill the autoshutoff min, with either Fourier transform method or findresonance. There are several examples online. As early as in 2008 Harvard is the first to demonstrate Q ~1 million from a phtonic crystal cavity.
If it is for transmission, autoshutoff min should be fulfilled. However it may not need about 12 hours. FDTD, in particular Lumerical FDTD is well designed for parallel distributed computing. However limited by the hardware configration and specs, the "scale" may not be linear as the number of cores. that said, more cores do not necessarily mean faster simulation. Too many cores for small jobs can actually hinder the simulation speed. You will need to test the Resource configuration and see how many cores/processes/threads are the most efficient, by checking the estimated simulation time.
I have a post for slow convergence: https://forum.ansys.com/forums/topic/ansys-insight-slow-convergence-in-fdtd/#post-205484
Please have a look.
If it is still a problem please give some screenshots for the device and FDTD settings. and if you have the premium support you can also email us.
July 12, 2023 at 11:44 amRuzanSubscriber
Thank you for your response.
I am interested in the transmission spectrum of the resonator array. I need to set autoshutoff to 10^-9 so that the transmittance spectrum looks reasonable. I use a point monitor to extract transmittance and phase, which is located 7 um away from the structure to ensure that I have a plane wave at the location of the point monitor. My operating wavelength is 1550 nm.
I will try the suggestions in the link to see whether I can reduce the simulation time.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Boost Ansys Fluent Simulations with AWS
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) helps engineers design products in which the flow of fluid components is a significant challenge. These different use cases often require large complex models to solve on a traditional workstation. Click here to join this event to learn how to leverage Ansys Fluids on the cloud, thanks to Ansys Gateway powered by AWS.
Earth Rescue – An Ansys Online Series
The climate crisis is here. But so is the human ingenuity to fight it. Earth Rescue reveals what visionary companies are doing today to engineer radical new ideas in the fight against climate change. Click here to watch the first episode.
Subscribe to the Ansys Blog to get great new content about the power of simulation delivered right to your email on a weekly basis. With content from Ansys experts, partners and customers you will learn about product development advances, thought leadership and trends and tips to better use Ansys tools. Sign up here.
- “Import optical generation” or “delta generation rate”?
- Why am I getting “process exited without calling finalize”, and how do I fix it?
- Using a license file on a new license server
- Ansys Insight: Diverging Simulations
- Error: addfdtd is not a valid function or a variable name
- Error on Lumerical device
- Questions about the calculation of the cross-polarization conversion efficiency of metasurface
- Ansys Insight: About override mesh in FDTD: its use and settings
- Finding your Ansys (or Lumerical) account number
- Lumerical – error message when trying to open from Linux terminal
© 2023 Copyright ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.