General Mechanical

General Mechanical

Topics relate to Mechanical Enterprise, Motion, Additive Print and more

Difference between Solid186 and Solid226 elements

    • Vasco Rasemann

      Hello fellow members of the forum,

      I'm coming to you to know the difference between the following elements: Solid186 and Solid226 (in a static structural analysis). I have two different mechanical models and one of them only has Hex20 elements, while the other has both Hex20 and Wed15 elements. My question here is, do Hex20 elements belong to the Solid186 family or Solid226 family? Or both? And do the Wed15 elements belong to the Solid226 or other? Finally, what are the main differences? 

      After reading the documentation, what I've observed is that Solid226 elements have piezoelectric capabilities. 

      Thank you in advance! 

    • Erik Kostson
      Ansys Employee







      The solid226 are coupled (multi) physics elements (so e.g., can be thermal+structural, thermal-electric, piezoelectric, etc.).

      Solid186 are single physics, pure structural elements (so used only for structural analysis).

      The element shape can be as you say HEX20 for both of these elements – in addition we can have wedge, prism, tet and pyramid shapes for both these element types (solid186 and 226). So the answer to your questions is both.

      So we use solid186 (default in static structural) if we are doing say a pure structural analysis. So Ansys will choose the correct element (solid226 or solid186) depending on the type of analysis used. So again if a static analysis is used, then solid186/185 are used, and if thermal-electric system/analysis is used then soild226 elements are used by Ansys.

      See the element reference manual inside ansys help for more info.

      All the best







Viewing 1 reply thread
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.